The Media Is Exploiting Colleen Slemmer And We Need To Stop Playing Along

The Media Is Exploiting Colleen Slemmer And We Need To Stop Playing Along

Every time a tragedy is packaged into a digital monument, we tell ourselves we are honoring the dead. We are not. We are consuming them.

The standard media playbook following a violent crime or a historical murder case relies on a predictable emotional formula. We get the grieving mother's quote. We get the adjectives meant to paint a pristine portrait of an innocent life cut short. "Vibrant," "generous," "full of promise." These words are deployed not to illuminate who the victim actually was as a complex, flawed, breathing human being, but to elevate them into a flat, untouchable icon of pure tragedy.

It is time to admit that this hagiography serves the audience's need for melodrama more than it respects the person who died.

When Colleen Slemmer was brutally murdered in Knoxville, Tennessee, in January 1995 by Christa Pike, Shadolla Peterson, and Marcie Pittman, the case immediately entered the dark pantheon of true crime lore. It had all the grotesque markers that sensationalist journalism feeds on: teenage perpetrators, occult undertones, premeditation, and a level of gratuitous cruelty that defies easy comprehension. Decades later, the internet still chews on the details. True crime YouTube channels, Reddit threads, and retrospective articles dredge up the trial transcripts, the graphic specifics, and the soundbites.

And at the center of it all is the mother's quote, trotted out to remind everyone that a good person died.

Of course a good person died. That is the baseline prerequisite for the public's shock and grief. But flattening a victim into a perpetual symbol of victimhood strips away their humanity just as effectively as the crime did. It turns a real human being with an entire internal life, bad days, poor choices, annoying habits, and unrealized ambitions into a stained-glass window.

We need to talk about why we do this.

The True Crime Industrial Complex And The Commodification Of Grief

The modern obsession with historical murders is an unregulated market of emotional voyeurism. Algorithms reward outrage, morbidity, and grief porn. When content creators package a 1990s murder case with high-contrast thumbnail images and solemn voiceovers, they are not engaged in historical preservation or justice. They are running a attention economy.

The lazy consensus in mainstream coverage is that consuming these stories is a form of empathy. We tell ourselves that remembering the victim keeps their memory alive. But ask yourself: how many people reading a deep-dive thread on the Slemmer case are actually thinking about Colleen as a person who walked the halls of Job Corps, had favorite songs, worried about her future, and experienced everyday adolescent struggles?

Almost nobody. They are tracking the plot points of a real-life horror movie. They are analyzing the psychology of Christa Pike like she is a television villain. They are treating a brutal, messy, devastating human tragedy as an interactive puzzle box.

When the media leads with the grieving mother's statement about her daughter being a "vibrant and generous presence," it functions as a moral shield for the consumer. It tells the reader: You are allowed to look at the blood and the courtroom photos because we started with a reminder that this was sad.

It is a transaction. Emotional absolution in exchange for clicks.

The Danger Of The Perfect Victim Narrative

There is a darker undercurrent to how society chooses which victims to mourn loudly and which ones to ignore. The "vibrant and generous" archetype is a requirement for public sympathy. If a victim was messy, troubled, difficult, or lived on the margins, the public narrative shifts. People start looking for fault lines. They ask what the person was doing in that situation, who they were hanging out with, or why they didn't make better choices.

This is a toxic cultural reflex. It implies that safety and respect are earned through compliance and perfection.

Colleen Slemmer was nineteen years old when she was killed. She was living away from home, enrolled in the Knoxville Job Corps Center, trying to build a path forward. Nineteen-year-olds are notoriously chaotic. They make bad calls. They misjudge people. They trust the wrong circles. None of that is an invitation for murder, and none of it requires a PR campaign from a devastated mother to make her life valuable.

Yet, the media insists on presenting victims through a saintly lens because the public struggles to process the murder of an ordinary, complicated human being. If we admit that victims are just regular people—sometimes annoying, sometimes rebellious, always flawed—we have to confront a terrifying reality: violence doesn't just happen to angels. It happens to anyone. And that is a much harder truth to sit with than a clean, sanitized story about a bright young girl whose only crime was being too nice.

Dismantling The Spectacle

If we genuinely want to respect the dead, we have to change how we consume and discuss these cases. That starts with recognizing the mechanics of the content machine we feed every time we click on a retrospective murder story.

First, stop confusing morbid curiosity with empathy. Watching a two-hour documentary breaking down the exact psychological profile of a teenage killer while treating the victim as a prop is not an act of remembrance. It is entertainment dressed up in solemnity.

Second, reject the demand for saintliness. Victims do not need to be described as angelic presences to deserve our outrage over their deaths. Their value was inherent in their humanity, not in how well their mothers could eulogize them to a reporter.

The next time you encounter a piece of content digging into a decades-old crime, look at the framing. Ask yourself whose interests are actually being served by the rehashing of the trauma. Is it shedding light on systemic failures, or is it just feeding a beast that never gets full?

Colleen Slemmer's life was defined by more than the worst twenty minutes of it. Until we learn how to talk about crime without turning human beings into character sketches for a true crime audience, we are just participating in the same exploitation under the guise of paying respects.

AH

Ava Hughes

A dedicated content strategist and editor, Ava Hughes brings clarity and depth to complex topics. Committed to informing readers with accuracy and insight.